secular music
short answer - enjoy it.
much of the modern church holds that secular music should not be enjoyed by the christian,
either because of the association, approval, or influence. personally, i don't think that
any of these arguments hold up on a global basis; influence is applicable on a personal
basis (rom. 14:23, mat. 5:29,30. really all of romans 14 could be applicable...), but no
more than any other possible influence.
common arguments against secular music
association -
association arguments follow the idea that because the music is produced by those serving satan,
christians should not listen to it. honestly, in my opinion, the reasons given for avoiding association
are always one of the next two (approval or influence), so there isn't much of a point here.
basically, arguments of association run aground on the example of christ. associating with sinners/
non-christians is explicitly done in the bible by jesus, paul, and others (read any gospel or acts).
approval -
the argument here is that listening/enjoying secular music is, or may be percieved as, agreement with
the non-christian origin or message of the song.
in my opinion, this is the reason most christians (who have trouble with secular music) hold. fundamentally,
it seems wrong to many people to appreciate/enjoy something which conveys a message that is diametrically
opposed to their beliefs (which much of current secular music is to christianity). i think that this
is misleading however: appreciation does not imply agreement.
it should be noted that there is no biblical command to not appreciate/enjoy something
that communicates ideas you disagree with; the argument should end with the presence or lack of such
a command. however, i think that examples can be given to illustrate the point that appreciating is
not the same thing as agreeing. music with lyrics that are anti-christian can be enjoyed on the
merits of the melody, harmony, etc., not withstanding the idea that one can appreciate the structure,
meter, and form of the words themselves though the ideas they express may be unacceptable to the
christian belief structure.
the idea that enjoyment constitues endorsement also prevents christians from enjoying the creative
expression of secular society. again, there is no biblical argument linking enjoyment to endorsement,
but its a common feeling. in my opinion, this seems to be the same issue as whether or not a christian
can enjoy the company of a non-christian; by enjoying the company of the non-christian, is the christian
endorsing the non-christian's 'enmity with god'? the answer here is a clear no, since the bible clearly
encourages such relationships (the gospels are full of examples and admonishments).
influence -
questions of influence invariably come down to case by case decisions; what causes one person to sin
might not cause another. jesus was without sin at the wedding at cana (john 2), but a former alchoholic
might have had a more difficult time (i'm not implying that drinking is a sin, but that a pattern of
drunkeness is). the guiding principle is not to do anything that might lead oneself to sin; flee
temptation.
demonic/spiritual influences -
some christians beleve that any music with a sufficiently loud beat is a channel for demons to curse
the listener. there is no biblical argument that holds water for this view, but there are plenty of
scary stories swapped in youth groups about missionaries who played 'christian' rock music only to
have the animistic natives approach the missionaries and ask why they were playing the music which
calls demons (the idea being that the natives used petra to place black magic curses, an idea which
sounds believable to my ears). as i'm not aware of any biblical arguments along these lines, i'll let
this rest.
music in the church
short answer : music is a great way to encourage and uplift the church, but it is currently often
used in a manner that reinforces mystical and extrabiblical tendencies.
the first thing to establish is that the new testament recommends music/singing as a method of
teaching, admonishing, and encouraging one another. col 3:16 (and eph. 5:19) states,
"let the word of christ richly dwell within you, with all wisdom teaching and admonishing
one another with psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing with thankfulness in your
hearts to God." i use the word 'recommends' instead of 'commands' because the tone of the verse
and passage seems to indicate that paul is presenting music as a possible (and for them, recommended)
means of 'teaching and admonish one another'.
historically, music has been used by the church for teaching and encouragement since its start;
eph 5:19,20 speaks of music as a social/corporal tool (col 3:16 is a parallel passage) by which we
encourage one another and offer thanks to god.