4:1 - 4:19 God lays out Israel's Sin
4:1 - 4:3 Israel's sins (social evils)
4:4 - 4:10 God will punish Israel
4:11 - 4:14 Israel's harlotry/idolatry
4:15 - 4:19 Summary of Israel's state
God's case against Israel: No faithfulness (4:1), no kindness (4:1), no knowledge of God (4:1, 6), they
have forgotten God's law (4:6), and idolatry/harlotry (4:12). 4:2 also mentions "swearing, deception, murder,
stealing and adultery."
4:4 "Yet let no one find fault, and let none offer reproof; for your people are like those who contend
with the priest"
Is this verse telling the Israelites not to blame others but to accept their guilt? Or is this
a statement that doing so would be useless because Israel wouldn't listen (they would even 'contend
with the priest')?
Important Verses
4:6 "My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge."
5:1 - 5:15 God predicts Israel's Judgement
Note that Judah is mentioned in this section; in 5:5 they are condemned with Israel, and in 5:12,13
they are included in the judgement.
5:12 mentions a 'King Jareb' in Assyria that Ephraim appealed to; Jareb may merely mean 'great' (the NIV
translates this as 'great king').
Important Verses
4:6 "My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge."
6:1 - 6:3 Appeal to return to the Lord
The final stage in the cycle (restoration) is not discussed fully at this point; 'restoration'
at this point is restricted to the call to Israel
Note : Who is the speaker here? ("Come, let us return to the Lord")
- brooke likes the option that Hosea is speaking to the Israelites on behalf of God but
as himself. She likes this view because Hosea is the author of the book, so an appeal
by him makes sense.
- taylor thinks that this may be Israel speaking collectively (figuratively); taylor argues
that Israel does speak collectively in the book (8:2, 10:8), and an appeal by Israel better
fits the restoration section.
6:4 - 7:16 God lays out Israel's Sin
Judah is included - 6:4, 6:11
6:7 - man or adam?
some translations say adam, some say man. (see the NET bible comment)
6:11 - is this good or bad?
brooke things that it is bad...taylor says it's a restoration idea...
7:11 - caught between egypt and assyria, done in by assyria
predicting who will be the one to judge them...
israel was trapped between the powers of egypt and assyria
Important Verses
6:6 "for I delight in loyalty rather than sacrifice, and in the knowledge of God rather
than burnt offeringso"
7:14 "and they do not cry to me from their heart when they wail on their beds;
for the sake of grain and new wine they assemble themselves, they turn away from me"
8:1 - 10:15 God predicts Israel's Judgement at the hands of Assyria
transition in 8:1
matches pattern of calling out as in 5:1
8:9 mentions assyria, 9:3 has assyria and egypt again.
9:9 and 10:9 reference the sin in gibeah
see judges 19
10:8 referenced in the nt
"then they will say to the mountains "cover us" and to the hills, "fall on us"
see luke 23:30
10:14 'as shalman destroyed beth-arbel on the day of battle'
seems to reference a battle that we don't know about.
10:15 bethel
"thus it will be done to you at bethel because of your great wickedness."
Important Verses
8:11, 12 "Since Ephriam has multiplied altars for sin, they have become altars of sinning for him.
though I wrote for him ten thousand precpets of My law, they are regarded as a strange thing."
10:12 "sow with a view to righteousness, reap in accordance with kindness; break up your fallow ground,
for it is time to seek the lord until he comes to rain righteousness on you."
11:1 - 11:12 God's desire for restoration
(a great chapter)
11:5,8,9 - god's great compassion
12:1 - 12:14 God looks over Israel's history and unfaithfulness
12:2 - judah referenced
this raises the question of whether judah is used for the southern kingdom or of
the north here.
12:4 - bethel referenced
where jacob met god... gen 28:10-22
13:1 - 13:16 God will devour them because of their sin
13:3 might be the transition...
13:7,8 - image of destruction by wild animals
13:14 referenced by paul in 1 cor 15:55
reference is wierd though - is it positive in hosea?
Important Verses
13:16 "samaria will be held guilty, for she has rebelled against her God. they will fall by the sword,
their little ones will be dashed in pieces, and their pregnant women will be ripped open."
14:1 - 14:9 God promises to love them, heal them, root them
read it and weep...